With all the news of historic election results, Bob Dylan meeting the pope, the pope’s visit to South America and the rest, it could be very easy to miss what I consider one of the most consequential papal statements of our generation.

In April, Pope Leo said: The unity or vision of the church should not revolve around sexual matters. Questions of sexual morality are not the sole nor paramount ethical concerns for the church.
We tend to think that when the church is talking about morality, that the only morality issue is sexual. In reality, I believe there are much greater and more important issues such as justice, equality, freedom of men and women, freedom of religion, that would all take priority before that particular issue.
In 2013, Pope Francis said something very similar: We cannot insist only on issues related to abortion, gay marriage and the use of contraceptive methods…The church’s pastoral ministry cannot be obsessed with the transmission of a disjointed multitude of doctrines to be imposed insistently. The New York Times reported that Francis’s comments “sent ‘shock waves’ through the church” altering its “‘tone’ without changing its doctrine.”*
Pope Francis put it in another and colorful way when he spoke of “anti-condom zealots” who want to “stick the whole world inside a condom.”**
Cardinal Robert McElroy of Washington D.C., appointed by Pope Leo, points out that in the 17th century sexual sins were considered mortal offenses, but this teaching fails to fit the entirety of Catholic moral teaching.
The 17th century was marked by extreme dualism, pessimism and guilt–Jean Delumeau, writes of “The Emergence of a Western Guilt Culture.” Flemish Bishop Cornelius Jansen (1585-1638), after whom the controversial heresy of Jansenism was named, published one book: its title was Augustinus.
Augustine’s dualistic theology separates nature from grace and is not at home with a cosmic Christ or sexuality. This makes Pope Leo’s, the first Augustinian pope, pronouncements on the secondary place that sexual issues play in morality to be especially consequential.
Since Pope Paul VI’s ill-advised encyclical on Humane Vitae (1968) that condemned birth control, the Catholic Church has been torn into two camps: Those who think sexual sins are the most important (though they don’t necessarily practice what they preach); and those who see social sins as the most important. The right wing has held up the former as the litmus test of orthodoxy.
By declaring unequivocally that social sins are what is the most important, the two American popes turn their back on 17th century Jansenism that has haunted Western Christianity for centuries.
Sexual morality carries less importance than foundation issues of human dignity and justice.

That Pope Leo is speaking clearly about this subject is especially significant. Why? Because he is an Augustinian and Augustine, deeply influenced by Neo-Platonism and even Manichaeism at one time in his life, carried guilt for his sexual escapades as a young man before his conversion to Christianity. He also identified his idea of “original sin” with our concupiscence.
As Father Chenu, great historian and theologian and father of liberation theology and creation spirituality put it: Matter is divinely willed and therefore good….Christians should not forget the fact that Augustine was a victim of Manichaeism for no small part of his life and that all life long he was hunted by an unusually negative experience of uncontrolled passion.
But given the dynamic unity of the human reality, the instincts, the sensuality, and the tensions which are at the root of the passions are all authentic elements of the virtuous life; they share in the dignity of reason and love, and therefore in the human—and divine—values of our lives.***
Kudos to the first two American popes for clarifying the primary vs. secondary moral issues of our time.
* Ryan Di Corpo, “Remarks on sexual ethics highlight Pope Leo’s pastoral priorities,” Outreach, April 24, 2026.
** See Matthew Fox, Letters to Pope Francis, p. 19.
*** M. C. Chenu, “Body and Body Politic in the Creation Spirituality of Thomas Aquinas,” in Fox, ed., Western Spirituality: Historical Roots, Ecumenical Routes, p. 200.
To read the transcript of Matthew Fox’s video meditation, click HERE.
Banner Image: Protesters of the social sin of ICE deportation raids in Chicago (Pope Leo’s hometown). Photo by Charles Edward Miller. Wikimedia Commons.
Queries for Contemplation
Do you recognize the lifting of excessive guilt and preoccupation around sexual issues to be a positive move that opens the door for more attention to be paid on the evils of injustice? And also more acknowledgment of the mystical aspects of human sexuality such as the Song of Songs represents?
Related Readings by Matthew Fox
Letters to Pope Francis.
Fox, ed., Western Spirituality: Historical Roots, Ecumenical Routes.
Original Blessing: A Primer in Creation Spirituality.
The Beloved Will Guide You: John of the Cross & the Triple Dark Night of Our Times.
Whee! We, wee All the Way Home: Toward a Sensual, Prophetic Spirituality.
Creation Spirituality: Liberating Gifts for the Peoples of the Earth.
A Spirituality Named Compassion: Uniting Mystical Awareness with Social Justice.
Charles Burack, ed., Matthew Fox: Essential Writings on Creation Spirituality.
Adam Bucko and Matthew Fox, Occupy Spirituality: A Radical Vision for a New Generation.
6 thoughts on “Kudos to Two American Popes for Recognizing Social Sins over Sexual Ones”
I believe that the widespread guilt and preoccupation around sexual issues are a measure of the embryonic state of human consciousness and of our extremely narrow understanding of Eros.
In his 1922 seminal “Vom kosmogonischen Eros” (Of Cosmogonic Eros), German biocentrist philosopher Ludwig Klages reinstates Eros to its rightful dimension of primordial cosmic force preceding and overriding that of Logos. His view of Eros as the primary force behind cosmic evolution (“cosmogonic” means “generator of cosmos”) is not unlike Meister Eckhart’s description of God as a woman on a maternity bed endlessly giving birth (e.g. DM of Feb. 7, 2022, by Matthew Fox).
To illustrate the shallowness of our association of Eros with sexual stimulation Klages writes: “If it is true that Eros is a state of voluptuousness, the sexual drive plays a part in it only in the most fleeting way—just as one who leaps through a fire shares in the glow of the flames—but it is no more Eros itself than one who passes through the flame is the flame. By calling the sexual drive a reproductive instinct, one had undoubtedly missed its essence; one would miss it just as much if one called it a drive toward pleasure.”
So much for our erotic hoopla seasoned with guilt, shame and a great deal of hypocrisy.
Where do the evils of injustice begin and end, and who’s to decide? It is written that if you look for evil you are bound to find it. The Christian Church has been obsessed with this search. Instead the focus, and the single greatest failure of the convoluted Christian Church, needs to be upon Resurrection! How is it obtained; what are the steps we must take in order to reach and experience this most elevated state of ecstasy and purpose? Inspire us with the whole Miracle of Creation and the singular Glory of God! Such an approach and understanding would lead humanity away from the temptations of sin into a collective human aspiration for Greatness, dispelling all forms of individuality, ego and selfishness! That, surely, was and is the Message of Christ and not this endless groveling about in the bottom of the barrel picking over all that is wrong. (Nothing like a good rant first thing on a Monday morning…!)
YES! YES! Well stated Matthew! The Beauty and Joy of the Sacred Feminine and natural human sexuality has been distorted in human history up to the present day in many ways that it has negatively affected the Spirit of Divine Love in Our intimate relationships with the many manifestations of Sacred Mother Nature, Our Sacred relationships with one another and All Life, including all physical and nonphysical spiritual dimensions/Beings, Our Sacred Living Cosmos, and Our Compassionate Human evolution with All of Sacred Diverse Life in the Sacred Process of the Eternal Present Moment…
The Catholic Church’s issues with sex stuff has been the primary reason I hold them at arms length, and will continue to do so until official doctrine changes. I will never forget my Catholic in-laws stating plainly to my husband and me, after we adopted our two children, and got officially married, that they don’t approve of gay marriage because of their religion. I’ve forgiven them, but that hurt. Especially when, to your point, they don’t practice what they preach. (I’ve personally had encounters with more than one Catholic priest. Shh..)
I’m all for encouraging signs from popes, but I’ve been waiting 60 years for doctrine to change. It has caused immeasurable damage to real people. They should be ashamed.
People have sex. All kinds of sex. They always have. (And straight people are way freakier than most gay people.) Children shouldn’t be born into inescapable poverty. Focus on relieving the poverty! Birth control should be available to all who want it. Eros is a way to connect with the divine. Gender is a social construct.
All of this nonsense is just religion using power to control people, just like fascists do. It’s about power and money. This is the part of religion I distrust and detest. It makes it hard to embrace the other parts.
I’m all for signs of hope – I just won’t get too excited until there’s official ACTION. Be bold and historic – change the damn doctrine!!!
Great comments here today. I like Pope Leo’s direction but don’t see the
Catholic Church changing doctrine and its rigid interpretation in my lifetime.
Change would imply a level of humility it simply does not have.
Augustine and his successors figured it all out you know
A few important points:
“Neo-Platonism” is the name for the type of Mysticism which gave us Meister Eckhart, along with Augustine, Plotinus, and the authors of the first book of Genesis, the Mystical Revelation of Moses, and the Mystical Revelation behind the God-and-“Logos” of the Gospel of John, along with St. John of the Cross and many others. They differ on their individualistic interpretations at the HUMAN level of the Mystical-Logos spectrum, but they all converge into the One at the foundational level of their method AND descriptions. They are the SAME MYSTICISM, witnessed by different people at different times in different communities. They also MUST BE the same to qualify as “Judeo-Christian” because that is precisely the origin of monotheism, of our God and our Christ. That’s why the Mystical code was included at the very beginning in both the Old and New Testaments, as well as in the original creeds of faith. This Mysticism is essential to our religion. Without it, we would be polytheistic.
Second, Augustine was a Neo-platonic Mystic who wrote some very penetrating Christian mystical works. He may have fixated on guilt later in life, but he had some very interesting things to say about the Mystical God first.