The Banality of Evil Redux: 12 Catholic Bishops Should Wear Sack Cloth & Ashes

In yesterday’s DM, I shared one of Rudolf Steiner’s last public talks where he challenged Catholic priests that the “main thing” must be to resist sentimentalism and include evil when talking of spirit.

The craziness that is Paula White-Cain. Now This Impact.

Lo and behold! On completing my article, I saw these truly scary headlines including photos and a video promulgated by Trump’s media team and the head of the “White House faith office,” Paula White-Cain. Called a “Christian nationalist” and “Christian Trumpist,” she has declared that: “Christians that don’t support Trump will have to answer to God.”

The headlines in the National Catholic Reporter read: “Ahead of elections, White House shares video of Catholic bishops praying over Trump.” A follow up headline reads: “White House names 12 bishops who prayed with Trump, defends president’s record.”

If this isn’t the banality of evil redux, I don’t know what is. I have asked my staff to send each of these bishops a copy of my book, Trump & The MAGA Movement as ANTICHRIST: Recognizing the Archetype of Evil in Our Time.  

The religious media is itself not without blame. Many in the religious press have never bothered to review or even mention my book even as this all-important election looms. Like Steiner warned against, they seem at home leaving evil out of the discussion on spirit.

White House spokesperson Taylor Rogers told the NCR, “There has never been a greater president for Catholic America than President Trump.” Dismantling Roe v. Wade makes some bishops cheer and forget everything else Trump does. Such as the litany of mortal sins Charlotte Clymer and I recounted in Monday’s DM.

Catholic bishops pray over Trump. Off the Press.

If anyone is wondering why more and more Americans are identifying as “spiritual, but not religious” these days, consider the video of these bishops blessing the MAGA president in the Oval Office 12 days before a most critical election!

Pope John Paul II getting in bed with Reagan in the 1980’s in exchange for cash from the CIA to denounce Liberation Theology and base communities in Latin America; his Vatican denouncing Archbishop Romero who was later martyred (and canonized) for his support of the poor in El Salvador; the rushing into canonization of Josemaría Escrivá, fascist priest and founder of Opus Dei in record time and changing the rules of canonization to do so; green-lighting Opus Dei—see Gareth Gore, Opus: The Cult of Dark Money, Human Tragedy & Right-Wing Conspiracy inside the Catholic Church; the truth of how six current Supreme Court members are connected directly and indirectly to Opus Dei thanks to the behind the scenes work of now billionaire Catholic Leopold Leo; the previous head of the American Bishops Conference being a member of Opus Dei; the denouncing and silencing of 108 Catholic theologians resulting in the fact that “theology is dead in Europe” as one European theologian told me years ago; the papacy being “in schism” as Father Schillebeeckx told me he and many European theologians believed about that religious era when two popes over 34 years turned their back on the spirit and teachings of Vatican II. All this and so much more lays bare the shadow side to the legacy of two fascist popes in our time.

Pope Leo XIV with the media on May 12, 2025 (cropped). Photo by Edgar Beltrán, The Pillar. Wikimedia Commons.

While I am upset by this public display of Episcopal banality of evil, I cannot say I am totally surprised. I have researched the interaction of fascism and the Roman Catholic Church in our time and blown the whistle in my book, The Pope’s War.

Fortunately, we have been blessed with two popes, Francis and Leo, who are trying to turn the ship around. To its credit, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops distanced itself from the White House event saying the meeting was not organized by the conference. But the Heritage foundation, nesting place for Leonard Leo, was behind it. The 12 bishops now claim that they were deceived by the president and Paula White-Cain.


Banner image: Catholic bishops in procession. Photo by Reiley Costa on Unsplash


Queries for Contemplation

Monsignor Arthur Holquin asked, “What were they thinking?” Bishops allowing themselves “to be staged, on camera, in the Oval Office, during an election the president is actively campaigning in?” Cathleen Kaveny, a law and theology professor at Boston College called the act “highly imprudent.” What would you call it?


Related Reading by Matthew Fox

The Pope’s War: How Ratzinger’s Secret Crusade Imperiled the Church and How It Can Be Saved.

Trump & the MAGA Movement as Anti-Christ: Recognizing the Archetype of Evil in Our Time.

Sins of the Spirit, Blessings of the Flesh: Transforming Evil in Soul and Society.

“On Desentimentalizing Spirituality,” in Fox, Wrestling with the Prophets: Essays on Creation Spirituality and Everyday Life, pp 297-315.

Original Blessing: A Primer in Creation Spirituality.

Creation Spirituality: Liberating Gifts for the Peoples of the Earth.

A Spirituality Named Compassion: Uniting Mystical Awareness with Social Justice

Charles Burack, ed., Matthew Fox: Essential Writings on Creation Spirituality.

Adam Bucko and Matthew Fox, Occupy Spirituality: A Radical Vision for a New Generation.


Responses are welcomed. To add your comment, please click HERE or scroll to the bottom of the page.

Share this meditation

Facebook
Twitter
Email

Daily Meditations with Matthew Fox is made possible through the generosity of donors. Please consider making a tax-deductible donation

Search Meditations

Categories

Categories

Archives

Archives

Receive our daily meditations

15 thoughts on “The Banality of Evil Redux: 12 Catholic Bishops Should Wear Sack Cloth & Ashes”

  1. I would not call this obscene display of sucking up to the king of tartuffism “highly imprudent,” I call it shameful, disgusting and, to be in sync with the latest DMs, a blatant example of evil in frocks. Whatever the qualifier, that pathetic and blasphemous spectacle would be enough to make me run away from that kind of Christianism had I not already done so years ago. Should Christ return, they would probably lock him up in Alligator Alcatraz or crucify him again.

    1. Today’s DM perfectly illustrates why I can no longer feel part of the religion and faith practice it extols. Pathetic. Fraudulent and Phony just like the one
      they pray with.

      1. Our bishop in Milwaukee publicly apologized for accepted the invitation. He said he felt tricked when Trump’s media team publicized the event without their permission. He says he chose to attend only because he felt it might give him an opportunity to speak with Trump about what’s being done that’s very wrong.

        1. I don’t think any of those bishops have been paying much attention. Knowing that this charade was sponsored by the Heritage Foundation (hello? Project 2025?!) should have been reason enough to completely distance themselves. And anyone who believes that they could have ANY influence on that whole bunch needs medication for their delusions.

  2. Matthew’s last sentence rings true to me. Cathleen Kaveny’s judgment that the bishops were “highly imprudent” does too. I would add the adjective “quixotic.” We love the idealism of the Man of La Mancha but blush at his inability to see the ugly facts. Twelve leaders of the Catholic Church tried praying that the Holy Spirit would get through to that reprehensible fellow in the gilded White House. The story isn’t over, I believe. The president might not reform, but come the midterm elections and time afterwards, better days will follow in the realm of God.

  3. Stupid. I would call it stupid. The notion that anyone could be deceived by the Trump regime or his minions at this point leads to no other conclusion than utter stupidity at best, and complicity at worst.

    All churches/religions in my opinion have good and evil within them. Just like the rest of us. We’re seeing the evil surfacing here. As has been pointed out, religion has a long history of seeking power at the expense of regular people, so it’s not a surprise to see it manifest in support for Trump. Churches are political organizations first, so they have a natural affinity with politicians.

    I have no use for religion. I believe they have done and continue to do more damage to the world and all its beings than any other singular group. Just think of all the wars and persecutions that have occurred and are happening today – all because of religions. Even our “dominion” over Earth is rooted in religion!

    Thankfully, people are realizing they can know god and pursue spiritual matters without being subjected to religious dogma and politics and drama. I think this is a very good thing. Not all religious people are evil, but yes all Religions definitely are. Also, important to note that “religious” does not mean “spiritual”.

  4. Complicity in evil. They knew full well what they were doing. Now that the heat has been turned up, they are playing the victim role—we were duped. Pure BS. They knew what they were doing. As long as Trump is opposed to abortion, they will reduce all morality to a single issue. Bottom line—they failed to man up. Penance—listen to Bishop Budde’s sermon to Trump 20 times and take a cleansing bath in the Ganges River 😁

    1. Mary Franceschini

      What the Bishop’s did was totally disgusting. Another insult to Jesus. Were they praying for his coversion or for him to win? The “One, Holy.,Catholic Church” has distanced me. Yes, have them wear sackcloth and ashes.

  5. To me this is a reminder that the Catholic Church is still a patriarchal institution with a very long shadow in history, and why I left it several years ago. My Faith is more interspiritual with-in the Divine Flow of Loving Diverse Oneness, including All physical/nonphysical spiritual dimensions/Beings, of Our evolving Beautiful Co-Creation Living Sacred Cosmos in the Sacred Process of the Eternal Present Moment….

  6. I beg to differ with Joseph, above. Perhaps I am also an innocent sheep among wolves, but I believe Archbishop Grob. If the only thing that made the bishops angry was publication of photos and videos, sure, I’d be pissed too. (As if they were okay praying with tRump, but not having photos of their prayers published.) Archbishop Grob gives a clearer picture of what happened. He says the bishops were invited to a White House meeting on domestic policy and human dignity. He felt he couldn’t pass up the chance to offer his voice. The bishops met only with staff for 90 minutes and then were ushered into the Oval Office where the president sat and “directed to stand behind him and pray.” The bishop’s apology, here, makes the White House’s game plan clear. Once again, it’s pure manipulation by the White House. https://www.archmil.org/posts/a-public-apology-archbishop-jeffrey-grob

  7. Michelle, I strongly disagree.
    I believe they knew exactly what they were doing and why! Invited by the Heritage Foundation they knew what was going on and willingly chose to pray over Trump. They are posing!! For the photo op!! Dare I call them Judas? Betraying Jesus and his teachings with a smile!!

  8. Why are people so quick to believe the spoke person from the White House instead of what the bishops are saying? I know Archbishop Grob and I believe he is sincere in his statement, admitting his mistake, and his apology.

  9. “He who is without sin, let him cast the first stone.” Evil, surely, is the absence of any compassion, forgiveness, mercy, tolerance, kindness and understanding. To condemn is easy; to investigate is more difficult but far more beneficial. As noted yesterday, one man’s evil is another man’s sacred. Where’s the wisdom of Solomon in all this or is the baby going out with the bath water?

  10. These Bishops are pretending to be “babes in the woods” — saying they had “no idea” their presence and praying in the White House would be used for political purposes. People so innocent should not be trying to be “spiritual leaders”. It is truly scandalous.

Leave a Comment

To help moderate the volume of responses, the Comment field is limited to 1500 characters (roughly 300 words), with one comment per person per day.

Please keep your comments focused on the topic of the day's Meditation.

As always, we look forward to your comments!!
The Daily Meditation Team

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join us in meditation that supports your compassionate action

Receive Matthew Fox's Daily Meditation by subscribing below: