I am waking up on the next day after elections in the State of Israel. President Herzog may still decide to ask his friend Bibi, the famous war criminal, to head the new government. It would not be surprising, given that Herzog himself has offered support to the genocide in Gaza, even though he tried to hide it under a veneer of respectability.

At the same time, a party that was started just one year ago challenged the murderous status quo and was voted in by half of the Jewish population of Israel. Its leader, Gadi Eisenkot, is a military man and a nationalist. Nonetheless, he might be rational and humane. Nowadays, it would be a wonderful surprise.
What the world needs — besides the ultimate triumph of spiritual democracy — is people who help us get out of the current frenzy of cruelty, disdain for human life, and lack of moral decency.
Eisenkot now controls 47 seats in parliament; the so-called Arab parties hold 19. Together they could easily overcome the 54 seats of the Likud and allies — the bloc mainly responsible for the genocide — and form a new government. Yet deep-seated suspicions, great differences in political platforms, and Herzog’s weight in the process may prevent such a desirable outcome.
Eisenkot does not support the two-state solution. On the surface, therefore, he is not good news to many who support the rightful desire of Palestinians to live in their own nation. I doubt, however, that somebody saying that they do support the two-state solution would have achieved any measure of success in these elections.
Fundamentally, Eisenkot and his party Yashar — the name means “honesty and truthfulness” — want the State of Israel to thrive as a liberal democratic state, instead of becoming a war-mongering superpower. How can this mean essentially anything else than the continued oppression of Palestinians, keeping them encaged in military-controlled areas with no real political rights and with a survival economy at best?
I find, however, between the lines in Eisenkot’s speeches, a hidden option which would upset everybody, and yet might be the only viable roadmap: the gradual inclusion of all Palestinians within the democratic process, with the final — yet unspeakable — aim to make citizens of all of them.
This solution would not give Palestinians a state. Israel, with its flag, will remain and control the territory “from the river to the sea” through progressive annexations which, in the long run, will be recognized internationally. The right of return for Palestinians will not become a reality. The state of Israel will become bicultural and bilingual, but with the Palestinian-born population soon overriding numerically the Israeli-born population.
Eisenkot presently advocates the immigration of millions of Jews to Israel. This seems to me an indication that he is thinking about balancing numerically the two components of the future state.
Is this a utopia or a dystopia? Maybe a realistic hope? The very fact that half of the Jewish population of Israel backed Eisenkot means something. Half of them are tired of war and massacres. They are gasping for something different.
We are confronted with enormous suffering and trauma spanning generations. It is very painful to accept — as many Jewish cultural figures have done around the world — that the heirs of the victims of Nazism have developed a Nazi mentality. That is the other half, the dark side of Israel today. Will Israel/Palestine become a laboratory of reconciliation and healing, or will it develop into an even more rotten and sad place?
Banner Image: 2026 election polling stations, Israel. Photo by Nizzan Cohen on Wikimedia Commons.
Queries for Contemplation
What feelings are evoked in you by the situation in Israel/Palestine? How are these feelings helpful to you, or could become helpful to you?
Related Readings by Matthew Fox
Adam Bucko and Matthew Fox, Occupy Spirituality: A Radical Vision for a New Generation
Creation Spirituality: Liberating Gifts for the Peoples of the Earth
TRUMP AND THE MAGA MOVEMENT AS ANTICHRIST: Recognizing the Archetype of Evil in Our Time
Sins of the Spirit, Blessings of the Flesh: Transforming Evil in Soul and Society
The Tao of Thomas Aquinas: Fierce Wisdom for Hard Times
One River, Many Wells: Wisdom Springing from Global Faiths
Prayer: A Radical Response to Life
The Hidden Spirituality of Men: Ten Metaphors to Awaken the Sacred Masculine
A Spirituality Named Compassion: Uniting Mystical Awareness with Social Justice
8 thoughts on “Two Halves”
The ideals of humanity are what we strive for but the realty of life situations overcome those ideals most of the time. That’s the human condition. So, the current situation in Israel makes me feel uncertain about the future of humanity. Fear, anger, hatred usually cause people to choose that which protects ir justifies those feelings. Sometimes this just makes me think or feel hopeless about the future of humanity.
The feelings evoked in me by the situation in Palestine/Israel are sadness and anger.
Sadness first, because I have no hope that justice will prevail in a land traditionally called Holy but made so unholy by a combination of shame, colonialism and cruelty.
Anger also, directed at all agents of the crimes perpetrated for the last 80 years in that part of the world with the complacency and complicity of the former Western colonial powers, as if the collective guilt for a genocide could be atoned in the blood of another genocide and the desecration of the cradle of our moribund civilization.
As far as the name “Honesty and Truthfulness” is concerned, another name called “Truth social” has made such words meaningless unless they are validated by concrete and courageous measures of atonement.
My dearest wish is to be proven wrong about this by a genuine Truth and Reconciliation process in Palestine/Israel.
There are those in the region, Jews and Palestinians, who value human life above the stripe of their religion. They seek collaboration and cooperation together. They lead the way towards a “spiritual democracy” mentioned here as the ideal. Being entrenched in any faith that advocates the destruction or the belittling of anyone of another faith is no Faith at all. We’re collective human beings and if we’ve forgotten that, AI will soon remind us of that reality.
For Israel / Palestine I have only tears.
From the origin land of so much spiritual wisdom continued madness
looms.
I was confused by the election results in Israel. You helped me understand the outcome. Thank you! I pray Bibi’s end is in sight.
Thank you for this detailed and thoughtful analysis. I won’t pretend to understand the nuances of the situation in Israel. It’s complex and I’ve never spent the time needed to fully grasp all the dynamics. However, it seems to me that this is a perfect example of religions being used to divide and separate humans, and “artificial” borders being used the same way.
I’m not naive but I do have a vision that transcends all this nonsense. I see a future that is much different than the present reality, and that’s where I choose to focus my energy. I ask myself this – what is stopping Jews and Palestinians from living together in peace? There is no answer I can come up with that isn’t some manifestation of evil. Where is the love? Why must the world endure so much drama from this place? What are we supposed to be learning? How can we make better choices? Until we can start answering some of these questions, and make different choices, nothing will change.
I am nearly 60 years old and this has been an issue my entire life. It doesn’t seem like we want it to change. We seem to like it the way it is – with the genocides and fascism and war. It doesn’t seem to matter who is leading which country. This is what we have chosen (collective we).
I have no respect to for Israel anymore. I also have no respect for Hezbollah, they are muderers. The two groups are the same. The vicious genocide in Gaza which tortures innocent Palestinians and targets health and aid workers is vile beyond understanding. The outrageous cruelty of the maniacal West Bank “settlers” , their beating and killing of Palestinians, journalists, even torturing, dragging to death Palestinian donkeys, burning olive orchards and Palestinian homes. all in the name of God. The settlers are a repulsive and murderous mob that the state of Israel not only allows, but encourages. They might as well issue them brown shirts. They have become Nazi Germany. They have become evil. I can’t summon warm spiritual sentiments about this anymore. I support Judaism like I would any faith, I no longer support Zionism until they radically change course and grow a damn conscience, and behave in a civilized, egalitarian manner.
Thank you GG for today’s DM summary of Israel’s recent election. My feelings and the feelings of most humanitarians around the world are compassionately expressed by Miriam Margolyes in the enclosed video.
In the footsteps of Brazil and Serbia in their recent elections, may the flow of spiritual democracy prevail in our upcoming elections in the US on Tuesday! God bless our human evolution around the world in incarnating our Source~Co-Creator’s Queendom/Kingdom on earth as It Is in Heaven…